We Are Scientists - Barbara
by Liz Perry 07/14/2010
Since the release of 2008’s Brain Thrust Mastery, We Are Scientists have
enlisted former Razorlight man Andy Burrows on drums and created and starred
in a series of short MTV mock-docs.
Listeners to this fourth album concerned about any comedy influence can rest
easy, though, as Brooklyn-based pair Keith Murray and Chris Cain have only
allowed the addition of Burrows to affect their day jobs. After all, one
Flight of the Conchords is enough.
WAS have long been a compelling live proposition, and have previously
impressed with singles like the bittersweet emo indie of After Hours and
breakthrough dance-punker The Great Escape. Barbara unexpectedly marks the
first occasion when they’ve delivered a truly consistent album.
The album’s zenith is surely ace drinking paean Jack & Ginger. Aside from the
verses of scuffed guitars and the cute kids TV show synth melody, there’s a
chunk of Elvis Costello regret in the chorus as Murray intones: “No matter
what I do, its way too late too late for self-control”.
Following tune Pittsburgh is another solid effort, albeit slower with wiry,
indie-psych guitars reminiscent of Mansun’s underrated Legacy single, with
poignant vocal harmonies and imposing Burrows drumming. Excellent album-closer
Central AC is perhaps the most surprising moment on Barbara. Powered by snappy
guitar riffs seemingly borrowed from Broken Bells’ equally excellent The Mall
and Misery, sped up and aggravated, its chorus explodes into happy-period
Beatles sunshine.
It’s not all about Murray and Burrows. Cain’s bass is allowed to shine on the
Rules Don’t Stop and notably I Don’t Bite. The latter is great fun, led by an
obese bassline that surely brought Cain’s bandmates and studio minions out in
lottery winner smiles.
Whether or not the addition of Burrows is solely responsible for the
improvement in consistency on this fourth album isn’t clear, but Barbara is
their best work by far. Current fans will be glad and new ones may be easier
to come by, particularly if the new material can be performed during festival
season with the zeal it is here. 4 STARS
